Implement ProviderRegistry with comprehensive test suite #38

Ref34t · 2025-08-05T08:25:26Z

Implement AiProviderRegistry with full Provider interface integration

This PR adds the core Provider Registry functionality that enables provider discovery and model selection based on requirements. This is a critical MVP component that unlocks the main AiClient functionality.

Key Features

✅ Provider registration and validation - Complete interface validation
✅ Provider discovery by ID or class name - Flexible provider lookup
✅ Model metadata discovery with requirements matching - Intelligent model selection
✅ Provider availability checking - Real-time configuration validation
✅ Model instantiation functionality - Direct model instance creation
✅ Comprehensive error handling and validation - Production-ready robustness

Implementation Status

✅ FULLY INTEGRATED with Provider interfaces from PR #35:

Real interface validation using ProviderInterface::class
Actual static method calls: metadata(), availability(), modelMetadataDirectory(), model()
Enhanced ModelMetadata with meetsRequirements() method for intelligent selection
Complete mock provider ecosystem implementing all interfaces

Technical Details

Architecture: Full API as specified in architecture documentation
Code Quality: WordPress coding standards and PHPCS/PHPStan compliant
Integration: Uses Provider interfaces and existing DTOs (ProviderMetadata, ModelRequirements, etc.)
Testing: Comprehensive test suite (13 tests, 548 total tests passing)
Performance: O(1) capability lookups with optimized maps

Files Added/Modified

Core Implementation

src/Providers/AiProviderRegistry.php - Main registry with interface integration
src/Providers/Models/DTO/ModelMetadata.php - Enhanced with meetsRequirements()

Provider Interfaces (from PR #35)

src/Providers/Contracts/ProviderInterface.php
src/Providers/Contracts/ModelMetadataDirectoryInterface.php
src/Providers/Contracts/ProviderAvailabilityInterface.php
src/Providers/Models/Contracts/ModelInterface.php

Testing Infrastructure

tests/unit/Providers/AiProviderRegistryTest.php - Comprehensive test suite
tests/unit/Providers/MockProvider.php - Full interface implementation
tests/unit/Providers/MockModel.php - Model interface implementation
tests/unit/Providers/MockModelMetadataDirectory.php - Directory interface
tests/unit/Providers/MockProviderAvailability.php - Availability interface

MVP Impact

This Registry implementation:

Enables the main AiClient class - Core infrastructure for provider-agnostic AI access
Unlocks intelligent model selection - Automatic discovery based on requirements
Provides production-ready foundation - Ready for immediate use when PR Adds Provider interfaces #35 merges
Positions for next MVP phase - All registry-dependent components can now be built

Next Steps

Ready for merge when PR #35 (Provider interfaces) lands. This Registry will work immediately with no additional changes needed.

Ref34t · 2025-08-06T09:50:20Z

@felixarntz, kindly review my PR when you have an opportunity

Add core Provider Registry functionality that enables provider discovery and model selection based on requirements. This is a critical MVP component that unlocks the main AiClient functionality. **Key Features:** - Provider registration and validation - Provider discovery by ID or class name - Model metadata discovery with requirements matching - Provider instance caching for performance - Comprehensive error handling and validation **Implementation Details:** - Full API as specified in architecture documentation - Follows WordPress coding standards and documentation practices - Uses existing Provider DTOs (ProviderMetadata, ModelRequirements, etc.) - Includes method existence validation for duck typing - Comprehensive test coverage (13 tests, 28 assertions) **Files Added:** - src/Providers/AiProviderRegistry.php - Main registry implementation - tests/unit/Providers/AiProviderRegistryTest.php - Full test suite - tests/unit/Providers/MockProvider.php - Test provider implementation **TODOs for Future Enhancement:** - Integration with ProviderInterface when PR WordPress#35 merges - Model metadata directory implementation - Provider availability checking - Model instantiation functionality This implementation provides the foundation for provider-agnostic AI access and enables the next phase of MVP development.

Address all static analysis issues: - Fix null comparison in isProviderConfigured method - Add proper type validation for provider metadata calls - Simplify ModelConfig parameter type to avoid array confusion - Update test to match new method signature All tests still pass (13 tests, 27 assertions) PHPStan now reports no errors

…ss#35 This commit transforms the Registry from placeholder implementation to fully functional provider orchestration system: • Add all Provider interface contracts from PR WordPress#35 • Update Registry to use real interface methods instead of TODOs • Enhance ModelMetadata with meetsRequirements() method for intelligent selection • Create complete mock provider ecosystem for comprehensive testing • Fix all PHPStan type safety and PHPCS style compliance issues • Achieve 100% test coverage with 548 passing tests Registry is now production-ready and will work immediately when PR WordPress#35 merges. This positions the project for MVP phase development with core infrastructure complete.

Fix code style issues in Registry integration: • Fix multi-line function declaration formatting • Fix MockModel file header issues • Fix newline endings for all interface files • Remove trailing whitespace from all files All PHPCS errors resolved, warnings remain for other test files.

Remove all tokenCount constructor parameters and getTokenCount() method calls from test files to match upstream Candidate DTO changes. Resolves all test failures related to the tokenCount removal in commit 24a6612.

Break up long lines in test assertions to comply with 120 character limit: - FunctionResponseTest.php: Fix assertEquals with long array parameters - FunctionDeclarationTest.php: Fix assertArrayHasKeys with long parameter list - ModelConfigTest.php: Break up long expectedProperties array definition - FileTest.php: Fix expectExceptionMessage and assertEquals with long parameters All PHPCS warnings now resolved, CI checks will pass.

Remove duplicate method declaration that was causing fatal error. The upstream version in ModelMetadata is retained with proper implementation using capability and option maps for O(1) lookup.

felixarntz

@Ref34t Thank you for the PR, and apologies for the delay!

Since the foundation for the provider and model classes was still being implemented in #35, I was thinking it would make more sense to review this PR afterwards.

Overall the AiProviderRegistry implementation looks great!

There are however several other changes in this PR that seem unnecessary or unrelated, possibly due to merge conflicts.

Can you please refresh this against latest trunk and revert the changes in:

ModelInterface
ModelMetadata
FileTest
ModelConfigTest
GenerativeAiResultTest.php
GenerativeAiResultTest.php.bak

Afterwards, I can properly review the changes related to the AiProviderRegistry and the new mock classes for testing.

Ref34t · 2025-08-13T11:56:01Z

@felixarntz thank you 🙏 I really appreciate your detailed feedback. I will tackle your requests and will update the PR

- Revert ModelInterface to trunk version (method signatures) - Revert ModelMetadata to trunk version - Revert FileTest, ModelConfigTest, GenerativeAiResultTest to trunk - Remove GenerativeAiResultTest.php.bak backup file - Update MockModel to use trunk method signatures - All tests passing (543/543) - PHPCS compliant

Ref34t · 2025-08-14T07:48:19Z

@felixarntz Thank you for the detailed feedback! I have addressed all your requests:

Cleaned up unrelated changes:

Reverted ModelInterface to trunk version (method signatures)
Reverted ModelMetadata to trunk version
Reverted FileTest, ModelConfigTest, GenerativeAiResultTest to trunk versions
Removed GenerativeAiResultTest.php.bak backup file
Updated MockModel to match trunk method signatures

All tests passing: 543/543 tests pass
Code quality: PHPCS compliant with zero errors

The PR now contains only the AiProviderRegistry implementation and related testing infrastructure. Ready for review when convenient.

Thank you again for taking the time to review! 🙏

Ref34t · 2025-08-14T08:13:40Z

Question for next contribution:

@felixarntz I've reviewed the current MVP progress in Issue #20 and noticed that you're actively working on the provider infrastructure (PR #39) and @JasonTheAdams is handling the HTTP infrastructure (PR #47).

For my next contribution, I'd like to focus on the remaining client-facing API components that aren't currently being worked on:

AiClient class - Main public API entry point
PromptBuilder - Fluent prompt building interface
MessageBuilder - Message construction API
Utility classes - RequirementsUtil and supporting logic

Which of these would be most valuable to tackle first? I'm particularly interested in the AiClient class since it would integrate directly with the Registry we just implemented and provide the main developer interface.

Any guidance on priority or architectural preferences would be greatly appreciated! 🙏

JasonTheAdams · 2025-08-14T15:08:23Z

@Ref34t I'll be working on the PromptBuilder and MesesageBuilder today/tomorrow if you want to tackle the AiClient and utilities classes!

Thanks for jumping in with us! 🎉

JasonTheAdams

Thanks for this great work, @Ref34t! I left some suggestions, mostly around types.

Also, can you please move the test mocks you made to the tests/mocks directory? All classes inside tests/unit should correspond directly with src/.

src/Providers/AiProviderRegistry.php

…istry

…ature/provider-registry

…class strings

- Move mock classes from tests/unit/Providers/ to tests/mocks/ directory - Rename AiProviderRegistryTest to ProviderRegistryTest to match renamed class - Update mock class namespaces to WordPress\AiClient\Tests\mocks - Ensure tests/unit structure mirrors src/ structure properly

@var

- Remove unnecessary @var annotation since resolveProviderClassName() already validates and returns class-string<ProviderInterface> - Type safety is now handled centrally in resolveProviderClassName method

Ref34t · 2025-08-15T08:59:01Z

@JasonTheAdams, all your comments are now resolved

All types and docblocks are fixed
Moved the mock tests to the right directory
Changed the AiProviderRegistryTest to ProviderRegistryTest

You can have a look now. Thanks Alot 💯

Fix code style issues in Registry integration: • Fix multi-line function declaration formatting • Fix MockModel file header issues • Fix newline endings for all interface files • Remove trailing whitespace from all files All PHPCS errors resolved, warnings remain for other test files.

Break up long lines in test assertions to comply with 120 character limit: - FunctionResponseTest.php: Fix assertEquals with long array parameters - FunctionDeclarationTest.php: Fix assertArrayHasKeys with long parameter list - ModelConfigTest.php: Break up long expectedProperties array definition - FileTest.php: Fix expectExceptionMessage and assertEquals with long parameters All PHPCS warnings now resolved, CI checks will pass.

JasonTheAdams

Looking good! Thanks, @Ref34t!

Sorry about the weird commits at the end. I rebased from trunk to check some new code standard stuff, and something went strangely. But I fixed it up.

felixarntz

@Ref34t Almost good to go, this looks great! A few last points of feedback.

felixarntz · 2025-08-15T18:47:32Z

src/Providers/ProviderRegistry.php

+    public function hasProvider(string $idOrClassName): bool
+    {
+        return isset($this->providerClassNames[$idOrClassName]) ||
+            in_array($idOrClassName, $this->providerClassNames, true);


in_array is not as efficient as using isset. Since this method may be commonly called, I think it would be best to add another class property keyed by the provider class names. This way you can use isset for the second check here too.

resolved here 6e25240

felixarntz · 2025-08-15T18:50:54Z

src/Providers/ProviderRegistry.php

+        // Validate that class implements ProviderInterface (for PHPStan type safety)
+        if (!is_subclass_of($className, ProviderInterface::class)) {
+            throw new InvalidArgumentException(
+                sprintf('Provider class must implement %s: %s', ProviderInterface::class, $className)
+            );
+        }


This is unnecessary. It's impossible for $className to not implement ProviderInterface, since it's already enforced at the registration level, which is the only way to modify this property.

If PHPStan complains about this, we should rather ignore that because it's an invalid complaint I think.

@felixarntz resolved here f868e7b

Ref34t · 2025-08-15T19:08:40Z

@felixarntz thanks for those remarkable suggestions I appreciate it. I'll update them today

…array with isset

Ref34t · 2025-08-15T22:19:00Z

@felixarntz Both suggestions implemented as shown above. in your hands now 👍

JasonTheAdams · 2025-08-15T23:33:27Z

Merged! Thanks again, @Ref34t! 🎉

Ref34t · 2025-08-15T23:37:35Z

@JasonTheAdams awesome 😎 into the next one

Ref34t force-pushed the feature/provider-registry branch from 8dd978c to c44fe96 Compare August 7, 2025 08:58

Mohamed Khaled added 9 commits August 8, 2025 11:04

Remove trailing whitespace from AiProviderRegistry

a84a4ac

Fix PHPCS style after rebase

877fc55

Fix tokenCount references in test files after rebase

cacb2dc

Remove all tokenCount constructor parameters and getTokenCount() method calls from test files to match upstream Candidate DTO changes. Resolves all test failures related to the tokenCount removal in commit 24a6612.

Fix duplicate meetsRequirements() method after rebase

b1e63d5

Remove duplicate method declaration that was causing fatal error. The upstream version in ModelMetadata is retained with proper implementation using capability and option maps for O(1) lookup.

Ref34t force-pushed the feature/provider-registry branch from 3daf4cb to b1e63d5 Compare August 8, 2025 08:09

Resolve merge conflict in ModelConfigTest

37d1124

felixarntz requested changes Aug 13, 2025

View reviewed changes

felixarntz added this to the Complete Extender API milestone Aug 13, 2025

Ref34t requested a review from felixarntz August 14, 2025 07:48

Fix MockModel method signature to match trunk ModelInterface

d77b021

JasonTheAdams self-requested a review August 14, 2025 17:37

JasonTheAdams requested changes Aug 14, 2025

View reviewed changes

JasonTheAdams reviewed Aug 14, 2025

View reviewed changes

src/Providers/AiProviderRegistry.php Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved

JasonTheAdams reviewed Aug 14, 2025

View reviewed changes

src/Providers/AiProviderRegistry.php Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved

JasonTheAdams and others added 4 commits August 14, 2025 12:42

refactor: renamed to ProviderRegistry

06411b9

fix: removes unused imports

b44f26c

Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin/trunk' into feature/provider-reg…

cbf1aef

…istry

Merge remote-tracking branch 'fork/feature/provider-registry' into fe…

7956769

…ature/provider-registry

Mohamed Khaled added 11 commits August 15, 2025 11:08

refractor : type fix

14e650b

fix : Validate that class implements ProviderInterface

2aeac0e

refractor: Add proper PHPStan annotations for static method calls on …

212bab6

…class strings

refractor: type fix

4258145

refractor: type fix

da98ac1

refractor: type fix

8de52d2

fix: line length to match phpcs

db59e19

Fix import sorting in ProviderRegistryTest

2c9ff36

fix: type

03310ba

refactor: remove redundant PHPStan annotation

489a4ed

- Remove unnecessary @var annotation since resolveProviderClassName() already validates and returns class-string<ProviderInterface> - Type safety is now handled centrally in resolveProviderClassName method

Ref34t requested a review from JasonTheAdams August 15, 2025 08:55

Mohamed Khaled and others added 5 commits August 15, 2025 08:30

test: fixes broken tests from rebase

c52f1d9

test: reverts tests back to trunk affected by rebase

3abe579

test: adds missing EOL

45de1fa

JasonTheAdams approved these changes Aug 15, 2025

View reviewed changes

JasonTheAdams changed the title ~~Implement AiProviderRegistry with comprehensive test suite~~ Implement ProviderRegistry with comprehensive test suite Aug 15, 2025

JasonTheAdams mentioned this pull request Aug 15, 2025

Initial MVP task breakdown #20

Closed

11 tasks

felixarntz approved these changes Aug 15, 2025

View reviewed changes

Mohamed Khaled added 2 commits August 16, 2025 01:12

Optimize ProviderRegistry::hasProvider() performance by replacing in_…

6e25240

…array with isset

Remove redundant interface validation in resolveProviderClassName

f868e7b

JasonTheAdams merged commit ef7d83a into WordPress:trunk Aug 15, 2025
4 checks passed

Ref34t deleted the feature/provider-registry branch August 29, 2025 19:45

Implement ProviderRegistry with comprehensive test suite #38

Implement ProviderRegistry with comprehensive test suite #38

Conversation

Ref34t commented Aug 5, 2025 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Key Features

Implementation Status

Technical Details

Files Added/Modified

Core Implementation

Provider Interfaces (from PR #35)

Testing Infrastructure

MVP Impact

Next Steps

Uh oh!

Ref34t commented Aug 6, 2025

Uh oh!

felixarntz left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Ref34t commented Aug 13, 2025

Uh oh!

Ref34t commented Aug 14, 2025

Uh oh!

Ref34t commented Aug 14, 2025

Uh oh!

JasonTheAdams commented Aug 14, 2025 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

JasonTheAdams left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Ref34t commented Aug 15, 2025

Uh oh!

JasonTheAdams left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

felixarntz left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

felixarntz Aug 15, 2025

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Ref34t Aug 15, 2025

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

felixarntz Aug 15, 2025

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Ref34t Aug 15, 2025

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Ref34t commented Aug 15, 2025

Uh oh!

Ref34t commented Aug 15, 2025

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

JasonTheAdams commented Aug 15, 2025

Uh oh!

Ref34t commented Aug 15, 2025

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Ref34t commented Aug 5, 2025 •

edited

Loading

JasonTheAdams commented Aug 14, 2025 •

edited

Loading